Chroniosuchia: Paper on osteoderm histology in online preview

...my first experience with bone histology:

Buchwitz, M., Witzmann, F., Voigt, S. & Golubev, V. in press. Osteoderm microstructure indicates the presence of a crocodylian-like trunk bracing system in a group of armoured basal tetrapods. Acta Zoologica, DOI: 10.1111/j.1463-6395.2011.00502.x

Abstract. The microstructure of dorsal osteoderms referred to the chroniosuchid taxa Chroniosuchus, Chroniosaurus, Madygenerpeton and cf. Uralerpeton is compared to existing data on the bystrowianid chroniosuchian Bystrowiella and further tetrapods. Chroniosuchid osteoderms are marked by thin internal and relatively thick external cortices that consist of lowly vascularised parallel-fibred bone. They are structured by growth marks and, in case of Madygenerpeton, by lines of arrested growth. The cancellous middle region is marked by a high degree of remodelling and a primary bone matrix of parallel-fibred bone that may include domains of interwoven structural fibres. Whereas the convergence of Bystrowiella and chroniosuchid osteoderms is not confirmed by our observations, the internal cortex of the latter displays a significant peculiarity: It contains distinct bundles of shallowly dipping Sharpey’s fibres with a cranio- or caudoventral orientation. We interpret this feature as indicative for the attachment of epaxial muscles which spanned several vertebral segments between the medioventral surface of the osteoderms and the transversal processes of the thoracic vertebrae. This finding endorses the hypothesis that the chroniosuchid osteoderm series was part of a crocodylian-like trunk bracing system that supported terrestrial locomotion. According to the measured range of osteoderm bone compactness, some chroniosuchian species may have had a more aquatic lifestyle than others.

Three recent papers on chroniosuchians

Buchwitz M, Voigt S. 2010. Peculiar carapace structure of a Triassic chroniosuchian implies evolutionary shift in trunk flexibility. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 30: 1697-1708. [Link]

Schoch RR, Voigt S, Buchwitz M. 2010. A chroniosuchid from the Triassic of Kyrgyzstan and analysis of chroniosuchian relationships. Zoological Journal of the Linnaean Society 160: 515-530. [Link]

Klembara J, Clack J, Čerňanský A. 2010. The anatomy of palate of Chroniosaurus dongusensis (Chroniosuchia, Chroniosuchidae) from the Upper Permian of Russia. Palaeontology 53: 1147-1153. [Link]

The redescription of the Chroniosaurus dongusensis palate by Klembara and colleagues adds further data to the morphological dataset provided by Clack and Klembara (2009) in their revision of C. dongusensis on the basis of a new specimen (which is the most complete of any yet known chroniosuchian). According to the updated phylogenetic analysis from the 2010 paper Chroniosaurus as the only included chroniosuchian taxon formed the sister group of embolomeres.

Schoch and colleagues (me included) describe Madygenerpeton pustulatus, a new species of chroniosuchians from the Middle to Late Triassic of Central Asia with a highly derived skull morphology and a carapace that was chroniosuchid-like in many aspects. The find shows that one lineage of chroniosuchids survived the Permian-Triassic boundary (by 20 or so million years).

The authors discuss characteristics uniting chroniosuchians with "higher reptiliomorphs" and unlike the approach of Klembara and colleagues their cladistic analysis, which includes five chroniosuchian taxa, results in a position of chroniosuchians somewhat closer to amniotes than to embolomeres. Chroniosaurus comes out as the closest relative of Madygenerpeton (both share the characteristic ornamentation of the skull and osteoderms besides other features).

Buchwitz & Voigt consider the functionality of chroniosuchian carapaces, comparing them to archosaur osteoderm systems. They argue that chroniosuchian carapaces basically served terrestrial locomotion but that the higher lateral flexibility of the Madygenerpeton osteoderm system was linked to a secondary increase in undulation swimming capability.

Reference:
Clack JA, Klembara J. 2009. An articulated specimen of Chroniosaurus dongusensis, and the morphology and relationships of the chroniosuchids. Special Papers in Palaeontology 81: 15-42. [Link]

Madygenerpeton pustulatus: first description finally out

Schoch, R. R., S. Voigt, and M. Buchwitz. 2010. A chroniosuchid from the Triassic of Kyrgyzstan and analysis of chroniosuchian relationships. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 160(3): 515-530. [Abstract]

Madygen News 2009

Expedition. This year's two month expedition to Madygen, Kyrgyzstan, ends in about a week. Rather than merely assembling more fossils the task for 2009 was to carry out further observations concerning the facies architecture and fine stratigraphy of the Madygen Formation - in fact to solve the evolution of the Madygen depositional environment throughout the time comprised by the Triassic sequence of the Madygen SW outcrop area.

Since the ways of communication between Germany and the Kyrgyz outback are difficult I didn't get much of an opportunity yet to talk to Madygen project leader Sebastian Voigt (my de facto chief who is still in the field). But from what I've heard the paleoenvironment is now well explained and some furthergoing approaches, e.g. comparing the conditions of Madygen to those of the other (few) terrestrial lagerstätten of the Triassic, are now feasible.

Symposia contributions and papers

- on the flora:

Moisan, P., H. Kerp, S. Voigt, C. Pott & M. Buchwitz (2009): Cycadophyte foliage from the Triassic Madygen Formation, SW Kyrgyzstan Central Asia. Terra Nova 2009/3:81-82. [Abstract Volume of Annual Meeting of the German Paleontological Society in Bonn] ... the respective paper is soon to come.

- on kazacharthran body and trace fossils: ... still in the review process.

- on fish:

Kogan, I., K. Schönberger, J. Fischer, S. Voigt & M. Buchwitz (2009): A nearly complete Saurichthys specimen from the Triassic of Madygen (Kyrgyzstan, Central Asia). Terra Nova 2009/3: 63-64.

A first note on this find will published at the end of 2009 in Freiberger Forschungshefte.

SVP poster on egg capsules and teeth of hybodont sharks, which have been discovered in 2008: Fischer, J., S. Voigt, M. Buchwitz & J.W. Schneider (2009): The selachian fauna from the non-marine Middle to Late Triassic Madygen Formation (Kyrgyzstan, Middle Asia): preliminary results. JVP 29 (3, suppl.): 95A-96A.

- on chroniosuchians:

Buchwitz, M. & S. Voigt (2009): Locomotion aspects of a chroniosuchid carapace. In: D. Schwarz-Wings, O. Wings & F. Sattler (eds.): 7th Annual Meeting of the European Association of Vertebrate Paleontologis - Abstract Volume. Aachen, 2009, p.14.

Buchwitz, M. & S. Voigt (2009): Phylogenetic and functional implications of the chroniosuchian osteoderm morphology. Terra Nova 2009/3: 25.

I'm trying hard to finish these manuscripts just now. The first description of the new chroniosuchid species, focussing on the skull features, is 'in press'.

- about the thing that must not be named:

Buchwitz, M., S. Voigt & J. Fischer (2009): Dorsal appendages of You-know-what reconsidered: aspects of development and the link to the evolution of filamentous integumentary structures. JVP 29 (3, suppl.): 72A.

...there is another longer manuscript putting some effort into the detailed description/documentation and a discussion of some rather modest model (... but I cannot really tell yet whether an 'accept' is feasible in the near future).

- on the depositional environment of the Lagerstätte Madygen and its tetrapod localities:

Voigt, S., M. Buchwitz, J. Fischer, P. Moisan & I. Kogan (2009): Lagerstätte Madygen - outstanding window to a continental Triassic ecosystem. JVP 29 (3, suppl.): 196A.

Buchwitz, M., S. Voigt, J. Hentschke & P. Moisan (2009): The Triassic Madygen Formation (Kyrgyzstan, Middle Asia) features a new tetrapod locality. Terra Nova 2009/3: 25-26.

...the latter poster introduces some (real) archosaur finds from 2008.

Chroniosuchians and stay in Moscow

To resolve the riddle: The bonified eyeball from the last post represents a a ball-shaped intercentrum of a chroniosuchid from the Permian of Russia.

In chroniosuchian reptiliomorphs the intercentra (white arrows) are interlocked with the amphicoelous pleurocentra in a ball-and-socket-like fashion. The image on the left shows some section of a Chroniosuchus vertebral column in ventral view. Intercentra become bony balls only in the adult individuals - not fully bonified in sub-adults and juveniles they are preserved with a crescent, disk-like or ellipsoidal shape.

Also, the fusion of the neural arch with the pleurocentrum - a feature otherwise characteristic for "higher reptiliomorphs" such as seymouriamorphs and diadectomorphs - is only completed in the course of ontogenesis (so that you can find suture lines in the subadult individuals).

Moscow: Paleontological Institute and Museum of the Russian Academy of Sciences (PIN)

The paleo-style PIN building has a castle-like rectangular shape with an inner courtyard featuring life-size sculptures of fossil critters from Russia and areas of the former Soviet Union. The exhibition has almost everything you wish for as a vertebrate enthusiast (here depicted: the two-story dinosaur hall). Rich in type specimens the collection is essential for some and important for many studies - so earlier or later many of the fossil vertebrate people spend some time there.

Concering the Chroniosuchia: With the exception of bystrowianid chroniosuchian remains from Kupferzell, Germany (Witzmann et al. 2008) and China (Young 1979) and some rather questionable Chinese chroniosuchid chroniosuchians (Li & Cheng 1999), all yet described Permian and Triassic chroniosuchian taxa come from the European part of Russia and are mostly archived in the PIN. I am thankful to Valery Golubev who helped me a lot during my week of stay when I was studying the type materials and to Jury Gubin who nicely put up with me in his room.

Some literature on chroniosuchians

Here considered: titles also available in English (plus the Chinese ones mentioned above).

Golubev, V. K. (1998). "Narrow-armored Chroniosuchians (Amphibia, Anthracosauromorpha) from the Late Permian of Eastern Europe." Paleontologicheskij Zhurnal 1998(3): 64- 73. [Russian, English]

Golubev, V. K. (1998). "Revision of the Late Permian chroniosuchians (Amphibia, Anthracosauromorpha) from Eastern Europe." Paleontologicheskij Zhurnal 1998(4): 68- 77. [Russian, English]

Golubev, V. K. (1999). "A new narrow-armored chroniosuchian (Amphibia, Anthracosauromorpha) from the Late Permian of the East Europe." Paleontologicheskij Zhurnal 1999(2): 43- 50. [Russian, English]

Li, J., Cheng Z. (1999). " New anthracosaur and temnospondyl amphibians from Gansu, China." Vertebrata PalAsiatica 37(3): 234- 247. [Chinese with English abstract]

Novikov, I. V., M.A. Shishkin (2000). "Triassic chroniosuchians (Amphibia, Anthracosauromorpha) and the evolution of the trunk dermal ossifications in the bystrowianids." Paleontological Journal 34(supplement): S165- S178. [English]

Novikov, I. V., M.A. Shishkin, V.K. Golubev (2000). Permian and Triassic anthracosaurs from Eastern Europe. The Age of Dinosaurs in Russia and Mongolia. M. A. S. M.J. Benton, D.M. Unwin, E.N. Kurochkin. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 60- 70. [English]

Witzmann, F., R.R. Schoch, M.W. Maisch (2008). "A relic basal tetrapod from the Middle Triassic of Germany." Naturwissenschaften 95(1): 67- 72. [English]

Young, C. C. (1979). "A new Late Permian fauna from Jiyuan, Honan." Vertebrata Palasiatica 17: 99- 113. [Chinese with English abstract]

Bonified eyeball

Or what the hell is this?

PALHERP Bonn 2009

The Meeting of the German Paleoherpetologists was launched in 1997 as an act of rebellion against the old mammal establishment which ruled the regular vertebrate workshops of the German Paleontological Society. A particular aspect of the Palherp is the relaxed atmosphere giving students the chance to present ideas and results without unfair senior criticism.

Last weekend the 13th Palherp meeting was held in Bonn. As the Steinmann Institute of Bonn University houses the German Research Foundation Unit on Sauropod Biology you can call it one of centres of paleoherpetology in Germany. Given the focus of the Bonn working group many of this year's presentations covered dinosaurs and/or bone histology.

Saturday: Martin Sander's keynote lecture on sauropod biology was followed by presentations on sauropodlet longbone histology, on rib histology and sauropod reproduction strategies.

The lower tetrapod session covered chroniosuchians, a pelycosaur jaw fragment as the earliest German amniote find, parareptiles and a basal diapsid.

In the afternoon a presentation on didactyle theropod footprints from the Oberkirchen Sandstone and a discussion of arguments/ phylogenetic analyses in favour of convergent flight origins in the Eumaniraptora followed. Furthermore a talk on finds from the Lower Muschelkalk of Winterwijk. H. Haubold discussed problems related to the continental P/T mass extinction event if it is taken as a dogma.

Sunday talks included the introduction of a new basal sauropod (from Niger), dinosaur palaeopathology, tooth morphology, isotope palaeontology, and 19th century history of dinosaur science.